Skip to content

Home
Menu
Specials
Hours
Education
About Us
Contact
Employment

34 Mill St, New Buffalo, PA 17069 | 717-834-6565 | Est. 1999

34 Mill St, New Buffalo, PA 17069 | 717-834-6565 est. 1999

Search for:

Home
Menu
Specials
Hours
Education
About Us
Contact
Employment

Search for:

Home
Menu
Specials
Hours
Education
About Us
Contact
Employment

Home
Menu
Specials
Hours
Education
About Us
Contact
Employment

Contact

(717) 834-6565

Name *

First

Last

Email *

Phone

Subject *

Email Name Message

Message *

Location:

Hours:

Monday & Tuesday: Closed
Wed & Thursday: 4pm-9pm
Friday & Saturday: 4pm-10pm
Sunday: 4pm-8pm

(717) 834-6565

DELIVERY AVAILABLE!

We deliver to New Buffalo, Watts Twp, Liverpool (including Ferryboat Campsites), Duncannon and a few other townships.

You can also give us a call (717-834-6565) during our operating hours and one of our staff will let you know if we deliver to your address.

Specials:

2 Large Cheese Pizzas – $27.98

1 Large Cheese Pizza with 2 Ham & Cheese Subs or 2 Italian Subs – $33.99

1 Large Cheese Pizza with 2 Cheese Steak Subs or 2 Chicken Cheese Steak Subs – $35.49

Everyday 5-7pm: 1 Large Cheese Pizza – $13.99

* Prices & Specials are subject to change without notice.

Copyright © 2026 Millie's Pizza — Website Development and SEO Services by CWS