About Us


Drone footage of New Buffalo PA by Cory Engle of Millie's Pizza

Located in the quiet town of New Buffalo, PA Millie’s Pizza has been proudly serving great pizza and subs since we first opened in February 1999.  Millie’s Pizza is owned and operated by Cory & Racheal Engle. 

The Engle Family of Millie's Pizza in New Buffalo PACory & Racheal both grew up in “blue collar families” and quickly learned an appreciation for their parents’ strong work ethic.  This appreciation extends to our customers who work hard for their money and deserve only the best quality service and food.

It is very rewarding for us to see families enjoying themselves with each other over a great meal in our dining room.  Our dining room is full of our rich local history dating back to the 1820’s.  The building that Millie’s Pizza is located in was at one time The Maple Leaf Inn from the canal days.  Our existing dining room also served as the dining room for the Inn in the 1920’s.  Our building at one time also served as the US Post Office for the residents of New Buffalo.  

We are also very proud that families from the surrounding communities of Watts Township, Duncannon and Liverpool, have welcomed us into their homes by using our outstanding delivery service.

Millie’s Pizza was named after Cory’s grandmother Mildred Trenn.  Grammy was well known for putting all her heart and love into the meals that she cooked for our family…and it is our hope that we bring the same thing to you and your family.

We have always taken great pride in our staff only hiring the sincerest and friendliest people from our communities.  We hope to serve you and your family soon!

(717) 834-6565